Selma’s Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room in San Juan Capistrano is a local favorite for authentic Chicago-style pizza, craft beer, and game-day energy. This family-friendly pizzeria, relaxed tap room, and lively sports bar offers deep-dish classics, thin-crust favorites, wings, salads, and rotating local brews on tap. Whether you’re meeting friends, watching the big game, or grabbing a casual meal with family, Selma’s delivers bold flavor, friendly service, and a true neighborhood atmosphere. Visit Selma’s Pizza in San Juan Capistrano for great food, great beer, and a great local experience.
Selma’s Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan 
31781 Camino Capistrano #201, San Juan Capistrano, CA 92675, USA
About Selma’s Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room San Juan
Great experience at Selma’s Chicago Pizzeria! Our hostess Jaedyn was excellent—super friendly and provided awesome service from start to finish. The deep dish pizza was delicious and definitely hit the spot. We’ll be back!”
The food was pretty spanking good, but I fear that it could have been better had we ordered the deep dish. We just weren’t that hungry, but needed to feed the little ones. The layout of the place is a bit awkward if you have got a stroller or such since the front door immediately goes up a few sets of stairs, but aside from that there was the heat. The restaurant ran a bit warm, but it could have just been because of the heater outside. The place seemed to be a family magnet as there were tons of kiddos inside. Gotta go back and check out the deep dish next time around~
the chicago style red sauce is digustingly salty. it is a layer of pure salt. whoever is making it needs to taste it before serving the pizza to customers.
Guys, I dunno what to tell ya... even when they are having a bad or off day, this place is still the spot to go. They never disappoint. 6 of us went in last night around 7:00 PM and it appeared there was only one person serving the floor and one bartender serving the bar area. Our server, Leslie C, did not make it even seem that way. She took great care of us and was keeping us informed along the way as well. I have a lot of health concerns and they were very helpful, knowledgeable, and kind about it. More servers like her. She deserves a raise, y'all!
Food was just fine. Nothing exceptional, but fine. Don't expect anything better than a TV dinner. Scaled with the price proportionally, which is a rarity in the Mission area of SJC. The atmosphere however is very lacking (extremely loud), and the service barely makes up for it, as they themselves get too rambunctious to be considered polite. Additionally, several front desk workers gazed expectantly at my girlfriend and I numerous times as we were waiting to be seated, but despite our body language heavily insinuating that we ready to be seated, we received not so much as a "we'll be right with you, thank you." Just blank stares. There was one lady however that was very friendly, so we appreciated the respectful demeanor. Unfortunately, our waitress was not so kind. She acted nice but the way she glared at us and other patrons was condescending and offensive. We were barely done with our food and she rudely slapped a payment tray onto our table without asking us if we were done. In addition to not feeling very welcome, the food was poor to just okay. By the second slice I could tell the crust was reheated and was so appalled I could not finish it. Overall Selma's is definitely not a place I'd recommend for good food, and definitely don't expect the service to be so cordial.