About Fifth Avenue Bagelry
Beyond their size, small businesses are defined by their spirit. And at the helm are their intrepid founders—scrappy, ambitious, and resilient. They invent and build things despite uncertainty, because it’s what drives them. Their risks lead to innovation that moves the world forward. And we need them.
Went around 9am for a breakfast sandwich. Ordered egg, cheese, and bacon on a plain bagel and it was really good. My friend ordered the #3 on a spinach and cheddar bagel which was even better! Tasted like a delicious pizza almost Customer service was great too. Very nice people who care about their customers
So friendly, great service and everything it's so tasty and delicious 😋 🤤
The staff is really nice and friendly. They have a whole amazing selection of different bagels. I got the cinnamon sugar one with butter and honey. I also got the summer chill smoothie. It was delicious. I took my meal to go, but the places does have tables if you want to sit and have your morning bagel there. Definitely will go back.
The atmosphere and the food were pretty good. They were sadly out of an Italian soda flavor I wanted but it’s not gonna stop me from coming back. The strawberry Italian soda definitely didn’t disappoint!
Update 2: This place is a controlled chaos on weekends. You order, pay, and wait/pray that you get what you ordered. Today the man (who was constantly shouting at the staff) behind the counter shouted my number and said they ran out of the bagle that I ordered, and asked if I wanted another flavor. Given his upset/aggressive demeanor I just nodded. This place reminds me of the Soup Nazi in Seinfeld. Update: this is one of my regular weekend brunch spots. However today after placing my order and paid, I waited 20+ minutes and still nobody called my number. Staff passed me several times and no one asked about what I was waiting for. This is AFTER all other customers who came after me have gotten their order and the place was almost empty. When I finally asked, NOBODY had any idea about my order (#19). The person who took my order apparently left the premise. Mysteriously my order was made but put aside and nobody in the shop knew about it. They had to search and finally found the lonely bag just sitting and getting cold. Will remove this place from my regular list for a while... Paying and getting neglected is NOT enjoyable. ----- Previous review: Popular with locals and for good reason. Bagels are always fresh. Service is prompt and courteous. Wide selection of bagels but will run out of certain varieties towards late morning. Wait time can be long but they will inform you ahead of time.